Business Impact To Insurers of Missing Schema Markup

Why Pet Insurance Companies Are Losing Customers

Introduction

When a pet owner searches for insurance coverage, they typically use three discovery pathways: traditional search engines like Google, AI-powered search assistants like ChatGPT or Claude, and voice-activated devices like Alexa. A pet insurance company without schema markup (structured data) is invisible on at least two of these three pathways. This article examines the quantifiable business impact of this omission, using the pet insurance sector as a case study.

Understanding Schema Markup

Schema markup is machine-readable code (typically JSON-LD format) that tells search engines and AI systems exactly what information is on a webpage. For a pet insurance company, this means clearly labelling product names, prices, coverage types, exclusions, claims processes, and customer ratings in a standardized format that machines can understand.

Without schema markup, a company’s website remains a “black box” to artificial intelligence systems—visible to humans but unintelligible to the machines that increasingly drive customer discovery.

The Traditional SEO Impact

Lower Search Rankings and Reduced Visibility

Insurance companies compete fiercely for keyword visibility. When a customer searches “best pet insurance for dogs,” search engines must guess what a page is about without schema markup. This guesswork leads to less precise indexing and lower rankings compared to competitors who have implemented structured data.

Search engines specifically use Product and Organization schema to display rich snippets—those enhanced search results showing price, ratings, and availability directly in search results. A pet insurance company without this markup cannot display review stars, premium prices, or coverage highlights inline with their search listing. This makes their result appear generic and less trustworthy compared to a competitor’s rich snippet.

Quantifiable CTR Loss

Research in the search marketing industry consistently shows that rich snippets increase click-through rates (CTR) by 15–30%. For a pet insurance company ranking fifth on Google for “pet insurance,” the difference between a standard listing and a rich snippet with star ratings and price information could mean the difference between receiving 200 clicks daily versus 140 clicks daily. Over a year, that’s approximately 21,900 lost visits.

Competitive Disadvantage

Pet insurance is a crowded market. Companies like Trupanion, Petplan, and newer entrants like Fetch are actively investing in schema markup and AI optimisation. A competitor who displays rich snippets with their coverage options, premium starting prices, and customer ratings will consistently outperform a competitor whose listing looks identical to any other website in the results.

The AI Discovery Impact: A Growing Channel

The significance of traditional SEO impact pales compared to the emerging challenge of AI discoverability. This represents a fundamentally new problem that schema markup directly addresses.

AI Search Blindness in Pet Insurance

When a customer asks ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, or Perplexity “What pet insurance should I buy for my puppy?”, the AI system searches its knowledge base for product information. Without structured data and schema markup, pet insurance companies are effectively invisible to these AI systems.

A customer using Claude to research pet insurance options receives recommendations based on publicly available, machine-readable data. Pet insurance companies without schema markup simply do not appear in these recommendations. Meanwhile, competitors with properly marked-up product information, pricing, and coverage details feature prominently in the AI’s responses.

The Pet Insurance Specific Problem

Pet insurance is a product category where customers actively use AI assistants to compare options. This is not a hypothetical concern—it is a growing behaviour pattern. A pet owner researching insurance for their recently adopted rescue dog will ask an AI assistant to compare coverage, pricing, and exclusions across providers. If a company like ABC Insurance (or any competing pet insurance provider) lacks schema markup, they simply will not appear in that comparison.

This means the customer never knows the company exists, never learns about their coverage options, and never has the opportunity to convert to a customer.

Voice Commerce and Emerging Channels

Voice assistants like Amazon Alexa increasingly recommend products and services based on structured data. When a customer asks “Alexa, what pet insurance providers are available?”, the responses rely entirely on machine-readable schema markup. Pet insurance companies without this infrastructure cannot be recommended through voice commerce channels—a gap that will widen as voice adoption increases.

Similarly, social commerce platforms like TikTok Shop and Instagram require product schema to display shopping features. As pet owners increasingly discover products through social channels, absence of schema markup means complete invisibility on these platforms.

Quantifying the Business Impact

Customer Acquisition Loss

A mid-sized pet insurance company typically acquires customers through:

• Organic search (35–40% of new customers)
• Paid advertising (30–35% of new customers)
• AI recommendations (15–20% of new customers, growing)
• Voice and social commerce (5–10% of new customers, growing)

A company without schema markup loses approximately 80% of the AI recommendation channel because their products are not discoverable by generative AI systems. If a company expects 100 new customers monthly, this represents 12–20 lost customers monthly, or 144–240 lost customers annually.

Financial Impact

Assuming an average customer lifetime value of £400–600 for a pet insurance customer (based on typical annual premiums of £200–300 and average retention of 2–3 years), losing 144–240 customers annually represents £57,600–144,000 in lost annual revenue.

This does not include the compounding effect: each lost customer is a potential source of referrals, reviews, and word-of-mouth marketing. The true loss is likely 30–50% higher when accounting for these indirect effects.

Advertising Cost Inflation

A company without AI discoverability must compensate by increasing paid advertising spend. Without organic discovery through AI systems, the company becomes entirely reliant on paid channels to compete for visibility. This typically requires a 20–40% increase in marketing spend to maintain customer acquisition rates.

For a company spending £100,000 monthly on Google Ads and Facebook marketing, this represents an additional £20,000–40,000 monthly cost, or £240,000–480,000 annually—a far larger impact than the baseline customer acquisition loss.

The Digital Obscurity Risk

The broader risk extends beyond immediate customer acquisition. Without schema markup and proper knowledge graph representation, pet insurance companies gradually disappear from the systems that increasingly drive discovery. This is termed “digital obscurity”—the phenomenon where a brand exists but is invisible to the machine systems that customers use to find it.

For pet insurance specifically, this creates a vicious cycle: without schema, the company cannot appear in AI recommendations. Without appearing in AI recommendations, the company remains unknown to this growing customer segment. Without this segment’s traffic, the company has no incentive to invest in schema. The company gradually becomes invisible in the channels where pet owners increasingly search.

Scenario: ABC Insurance

Consider a hypothetical pet insurance provider, ABC Insurance, that offers competitive pricing and good coverage but lacks schema markup on their website.

When a customer searches “pet insurance for dogs” on Google:

• A competitor with schema markup displays a rich snippet showing their policy starting price (£8/month), average customer rating (4.5 stars), and coverage highlights
• ABC Insurance appears as a standard listing with only a blue link and generic description
• The customer clicks the competitor

When the same customer asks Claude “What’s the best pet insurance for a young Golden Retriever with a history of allergies?”:

• Claude recommends three insurers that appear prominently in its training data with structured information
• ABC Insurance does not appear because their website lacks machine-readable product data
• The customer never learns ABC Insurance exists

When the customer uses their smart speaker to research options:

• Alexa recommends providers that have properly structured product data
• ABC Insurance cannot be recommended because voice systems cannot access their product information
• The customer never discovers them through this channel

Over a year, ABC Insurance loses hundreds of potential customers across these three discovery channels. Meanwhile, they must increase paid advertising spend 25–40% just to maintain their current customer acquisition rate against competitors who enjoy organic discoverability across all three channels.

The Path Forward

Pet insurance companies face a clear business case for implementing schema markup:

Immediate benefits include improved search visibility, rich snippet display, and higher click-through rates on Google. These deliver measurable improvements within 3–6 months.

Medium-term benefits include visibility in AI-powered search recommendations, voice commerce recommendations, and social commerce. These become increasingly valuable as customer behaviour shifts toward AI-assisted discovery.

Long-term benefits include protection against digital obscurity as search and discovery mechanisms evolve. Companies that implement schema markup now avoid the costly scramble to implement it later when the business impact becomes undeniable.

Conclusion

The business impact of missing schema markup for pet insurance companies is substantial and multifaceted. The direct impact—lower search rankings and reduced visibility—costs companies an estimated £50,000–£150,000 annually in lost customer acquisition. The indirect impact—increased advertising costs to compensate for lost organic discovery—costs an additional £200,000–£500,000 annually for mid-sized companies.

However, the largest impact is emerging and largely invisible: the loss of AI discoverability. As customers increasingly use ChatGPT, Claude, and other AI systems to research insurance options, companies without schema markup are gradually disappearing from the most important discovery channels of the future.

For pet insurance companies, schema markup is not an optional technical implementation. It is a business necessity for maintaining competitive visibility across the discovery channels that now drive customer acquisition.

Is your website invisible to AI search? You’d be barking mad not to fix it.
Contact [email protected]